Skip to main content

Press releasePublished on 20 November 2026

Climate pathways: weighing the environmental co-benefits and trade-offs

Villigen, 20.11.2026 — Decarbonisation benefits human health and ecosystem quality beyond reducing greenhouse gas emissions. But it does not consistently ease pressures on natural resources such as land, freshwater and minerals. A new study led by Paul Scherrer Institute PSI in Nature Energy compares the environmental impacts of 24 different global energy transition strategies.

The burning of fossil fuels such as coal, gas, and oil is the primary driver of climate change, but clean energy strategies to achieve net-zero greenhouse gas emissions do not systematically alleviate other environmental problems. In fact, some pathways add pressure on natural resources like land, water and minerals.

Until now, the broader environmental impacts of the energy transition, including the effects of low-carbon technologies on demand for critical raw materials, have received insufficient attention. A new study led by Alvaro Jose Hahn Menacho at the PSI Laboratory for Energy Systems Analysis (LEA) shows how pathways with a similar level of global warming can have very different impacts on mineral, land and water resources. Hahn Menacho explains, “different low-carbon energy technologies come with different co-benefits, but also trade-offs. It’s about finding the balanced portfolio that allows us to remain within biophysical boundaries.”

Informing clean energy infrastructure decisions with Premise

The study examines 24 climate mitigation pathways from the world’s leading Integrated Assessment Models (IAM), covering a broad range of socio-economic developments, climate ambition, and energy-system configurations. These pathways are coupled with prospective life-cycle assessment (LCA). While traditional LCA evaluates the environmental impacts of past or current technologies, prospective LCA looks at the environmental impacts of technologies into the future.

Prospective LCA has been made broadly accessible by Premise, an open-source tool developed by Romain Sacchi, also at PSI-LEA. Sacchi, a co-author of this study, explains, “Premise is the link that allows us to judge a net-zero scenario based on a much broader spectrum of indicators than cost and greenhouse gas emissions, which in the end tells us a lot more about whether a scenario is really sustainable or not.”

The findings can help policymakers assess whether a decarbonisation strategy supports not only climate goals but also broader environmental sustainability, before major infrastructure investment decisions are made. Examining decarbonisation scenarios through a wide spectrum of environmental and resource indicators, which Integrated Assessment Models typically do not quantify, helps reveal the trade-offs and wider benefits associated with different pathways.

Mineral resources: a matter of timing

Electrifying energy systems, key to reaching net-zero, will require mineral extraction to expand. Will we face shortages? Possibly, because faster, more ambitious decarbonisation accelerates the growth in mineral demand. However, the study finds that, although ambitious climate pathways require more minerals in the near term, less ambitious pathways ultimately demand more energy and require similar levels of resources in the long term, since the switch to more efficient electrified processes occurs later.

Beyond decarbonisation

The findings show that reaching net zero is not only a question of reducing greenhouse gas emissions. The wider environmental consequences vary considerably depending on the technologies and resources used. Land use by the energy system, for example, is strongly influenced by the use of biomass. Across the pathways studied, it ranges from a 13% decrease to a 354% increase. Water use rises in nearly all pathways, driven by growing demand for water in mining, material processing and cooling throughout expanding electricity supply chains.

Decarbonisation therefore brings substantial benefits, but it does not automatically reduce every form of environmental pressure. Demand for land, water and raw materials is likely to continue growing, making improvements in energy and resource efficiency essential to achieving the best overall outcomes, explains Hahn Menacho.

At the end of the day, says Sacchi, “it’s about sustainability, and sustainability is about more than just greenhouse gas emissions.”

This study was conducted by researchers at PSI, the Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research (PIK), the PBL Netherlands Environmental Assessment Agency, the Copernicus Institute of Sustainable Development in the Netherlands, the International Institute for Applied Systems Analysis in Austria, ETH Zurich, and TU Berlin. The authors received financial support of their work through the Swiss State Secretariat for Education, Research and Innovation (SERI), Horizon Europe, and the German Federal Ministry for Research, Technology and Space.

Text: Paul Scherrer Institute PSI/Carolyn Kerchof

About PSI

The Paul Scherrer Institute PSI is the largest research institute for natural and engineering sciences in Switzerland. It is the central location of Switzerland’s large research facilities, available to both the scientific community and industry. Its research spans future technologies, energy and climate, health innovation and fundamentals of nature. The annual budget is CHF 450 million. PSI employs 2300 people; around a quarter of these are postdoctoral researchers, PhD students or apprentices. PSI is part of the ETH Domain, which also includes ETH Zurich and ETH Lausanne, as well as the other federal research institutes Empa, Eawag and WSL.

Contact

Dr. Romain Sacchi
Laboratory for Energy Systems Analysis
Paul Scherrer Institute PSI

+41 56 310 57 64
romain.sacchi@psi.ch

Orignal publication

Environmental and material implications of global climate mitigation pathways
A.J. Hahn Menacho, D. Bantje, C. Bauer, N. Bauer, V. Daioglou, V. Krey, G. Luderer, F. Maczek, R. McKenna, R. Sacchi
Nature Energy, 20.11.2026 (online)
DOI: 10.1038/s41560-026-02171-x

To the press release